From One Older House to Three New Homes

By Jason Tarabokija, licensed New Jersey real estate salesperson with New Jersey Elite Group, LLC. ·

All case studies

Gray cape-style house with a gray roof and a white-railed front porch

One of our management clients was ready to go from buying single rentals to building new ones. We found an older house on an oversized parcel, and a survey confirmed the lot could be split into three. We negotiated a $930,000 price, which came in below what the land alone is worth, and the deal was signed in March 2026. The old house will come down, with three new homes planned for completion in summer 2027.

purchase price
$930,000
all-in cost per home (land plus build)
Under $710,000
expected sale price per home
$1M+
projected yearly gross rent on a 4-bedroom
$100K+

The numbers

  • Bought for $930,000 in March 2026 as a teardown on a lot that splits into three.
  • Three new homes planned for summer 2027, with build costs under $400,000 each.
  • That puts the all-in cost under $2.13 million, or about $710,000 per home.
  • Each home is expected to sell for over $1 million, a projected sell-out above $3 million.
  • The owner may keep one home and sell the other two. Two sales at $1 million or more would cover nearly the entire project, leaving him a new home that earns rent.
  • A new 4-bedroom here is projected to gross over $100,000 a year, in line with what a typical 4-bedroom Breezy home earned last year ($100,300).
  • This owner already has other homes in the Breezy portfolio.

Photos

  • Aerial view of an older gray-roofed house with a side yard among neighboring homes
  • Aerial view of a light blue house with a gray roof, a side yard and a white fence
  • Two-story gray building with a garage at the edge of a gravel yard
  • Aerial view of a beach town street grid between the ocean and the bay
  • Aerial of a bay and waterfront blocks with a red pin marking the property

Build costs, sale prices, and rent are projections, not guarantees. Figures do not include closing, selling, or carrying costs. Rent: after discounts, before platform fees and management, excluding cleaning fees.

All articles

Talk to Breezy about your property

See How We Manage Homes